PIERRE - State legislative leaders said Friday they may subpoena the promoter of a controversial ballot initiative to force him to answer questions about it.
Senate Majority Leader Eric Bogue, R-Faith, and Senate Minority Leader Garry
Moore, D-Yankton, expressed "shock" when a supporter of the proposed Judicial
Accountability Initiative Law, or JAIL, read a written statement at a meeting of
Senate State Affairs Committee, then refused to answer questions posed by
committee members.
The committee, which Bogue chairs, was considering a
resolution in opposition to the JAIL initiative, which will appear as Amendment
E on the November ballot. If approved by the voters, it would strip judges of
immunity from lawsuits.
Most of the state Legislature's 105 members have
signed on to the resolution in opposition to Amendment E, saying that the
measure would extend to everyone from county commissioners to volunteers who
serve on local boards.
They said the California-based JAIL movement chose
South Dakota because it is easier to get initiatives on the ballot
here.
Representatives of 19 organizations told committee members Friday
that Amendment E would have far-reaching ramifications, citing things such as a
negative impact on the state's economy and an inability to attract people to
public service.
After that testimony, Bill Stegmeier of Tea, who led the
South Dakota drive to get the measure on the ballot, read a five-page statement
to the committee.
"Your accusation that the amendment will put all public
servants at risk of being sued for doing nothing more than their jobs is
ludicrous," Stegmeier said.
When he was asked after his testimony to
respond to questions, Stegmeier said, "I respectfully decline to answer any
questions. I do not feel I am prepared."
He said he would respond to
written questions "at a later date."
"You were involved in putting this
on the ballot," Sen. Lee Schoenbeck, R-Watertown, said. "When do expect to be
prepared to explain it?"
"At a later date," Stegmeier
said.
"Before you decided to put the citizens of South Dakota through
this, did it not occur to you to understand it and be ready to explain it?"
Schoenbeck asked.
Stegmeier again declined to respond, saying that all of
his comments were included in the statement he read to the
committee.
Bogue then said that action would be delayed on the resolution
opposing Amendment E until the committee considers its options.
Later, at
separate press briefings, both Bogue and Moore said that may include a
subpoena.
"We have had a shocking and unprecedented event where an
individual appeared in front of a standing committee and refused to answer
questions," Bogue said. "In my 10 years here, that has never
happened."
He said the committee will decide whether to issue a
subpoena.
Bogue said that appearing before a committee and refusing to
answer questions is a Class 2 misdemeanor, which carries a maximum penalty of 30
days in jail, a fine of $200, or both.
"This is something that is going
to have a dramatic effect, whether you are a proponent or an opponent, on the
constitution and procedures at every level of South Dakota government," Bogue
said. "To have an individual who is a such a key component in putting this on
the ballot read a statement and then claim to be unwilling and unable to answer
questions, is appalling."
Moore said that during his 16 years as a
legislator, "I have never seen anything similar to what happened in the State
Affairs Committee today. � It is going to be interesting to see whether a
sheriff knocks on the door and subpoenas someone to testify next
week."
Moore said South Dakotans were "hoodwinked" when the initiative
got on the ballot.
"I would be ashamed to let anybody know I was a part
of that when they can't answer the questions," he said.
Contacted later,
Stegmeier said the written statement covered what he intended to talk
about.
"I did not care to debate five or six attorneys (on the committee)
on the amendment itself," he said.
When told the committee may issue a
subpoena, Stegmeier said, "That's fine. A subpoena will tell me what I need to
be prepared for."
Contact Celeste Calvitto at 394-8438
or
[email protected].
J.A.I.L.- Judicial Accountability Initiative Law -
www.jail4judges.org
Contribute to
J.A.I.L. at P.O. Box 207, N. Hollywood, CA 91603
See our active flash, http://www.jail4judges.org/Flash.htm
JAIL
is a unique addition to our form of gov't. heretofore unrealized.
JAIL is
powerful! JAIL is dynamic! JAIL is America's ONLY hope!
E-Group sign on at http://groups.yahoo.com/group/jail4judges/join
Get involved at [email protected]
To
be added or removed, write to [email protected]
Your
help is needed: www.sd-jail4judges.org
"..it
does not require a majority to prevail, but rather an irate, tireless
minority keen to set brush fires in people's minds.." - Samuel
Adams
"There are a thousand hacking at the branches of evil to one
who is
striking at the
root."
-- Henry David Thoreau
<><
Return To JNJ Library Index for All Years