IN THE SUPREME
COURT
OF
THE
STATE OF SOUTH
DAKOTA
*
* * *
WILLIAM
STEGMEIER,
)
Applicant and
Appellant, )
) JUDGMENT OF
AFFIRMANCE
vs.
)
)
#24239, #24241
LARRY LONG, SOUTH
DAKOTA )
ATTORNEY GENERAL,
AND )
CHRIS NELSON,
SECRETARY )
OF
STATE,
)
Respondents and Appellees.
)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The above-entitled matter came before this Court on an expedited appeal
from
a circuit court
judgment and order denying, in part, and granting, in part, writ of
certiorari.
There is no dispute that this matter must be resolved by September 1,
2006, so that the
ballot printing process may begin and voters will not be
disenfranchised.
Having received the appeal briefs late Wednesday, August 30, 2006, in the
limited time
available, this Court has thoroughly considered the briefs and exhibits.
We observe that the
applicant has abandoned the argument that Constitutional
Amendment E applies
only to judges. Thus the only remaining issues applicant
raises are whether
"the attorney general's explanation of proposed Amendment E
exceeds the power
and authority conferred upon him by SDCL 12-13-9" and
whether "the ballot
statement as released by the attorney general is misleading,
factually
inaccurate, and legally inaccurate."
We have reviewed this case to determine if the attorney general has
exceeded
his jurisdiction,
SDCL 21-31-1, and properly complied with his legal duties under
SDCL 12-13-9.
We conclude that the attorney general's ballot explanation, as
corrected by the
circuit court, educates the voters of the purpose, effect, and legal
consequences of
Constitutional Amendment E and fully complies with SDCL
12-13-9.
Accordingly, we affirm, in all respects, the circuit court's judgment and
order
denying, in part,
and granting, in part, writ of certiorari.
DATED at Pierre, South Dakota, this 31st day of August,
2006.
BY THE COURT:
/signature/
Richard W. Sabers,
Acting Chief Justice
ATTEST:
/signature/
Clerk of the Supreme
Court
(SEAL)
(Justice Sabers
agrees with the Court, except dissents in part on the basis that the attorney
general's ballot explanation fails to state the purpose of the Constitutional
Amendment E and, therefore, is not objective.)
PARTICIPATING:
Acting Chief Justice Richard W. Sabers, Justices John K. Konenkamp and Judith K.
Meierhenry, Circuit Court Judges Gene Paul Kean and John W. Bastian, serving in
the places of Chief Justice David Gilbertson and Justice Steven L. Zinter who
have deemed themselves disqualified.
(STAMPED)
SUPREME COURT
STATE OF SOUTH DAKOTA
AUG 31
2006
/ signature /
Clerk